There needs to be robust and open debate on the merits of expanding the export terminals. These terminals, which serve as a gateway to Asia, have been an important part of the regional economy for more than a century. Debate over the terminals should be grounded in scientific facts and analysis. Well-established scientific approaches should be used to evaluate any potential environmental and human-health impacts.
Scientific assessments such as the one being conducted by the Army Corps of Engineers should provide clarity and context for decisions by public officials. Science-based assessments should also identify any constraints needed to assure protection of the environment and public health. The public at large should encourage and, indeed, demand such assessments.
Until such assessments are completed, it is plainly irresponsible to release exaggerated claims and mislead the public and regulators about the impact of transporting coal through the Northwest.
Roger O. McClellan, an expert on toxicology and human health-risk analysis, is former chairman of the National Research Council Committee on Toxicology, past Chairman of EPA’s Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee, and a member of the Institute of Medicine. This is an excerpt from an op-ed piece he wrote for the Seattle Times.
Learn more about the Northwest coal export proposals at EarthFix.
Backers and critics of coal-fired power are waiting to see how tough the Obama administration gets on hundreds of plants as part of his pledge to cut greenhouse gas emissions. (Charlie Riedel / Associated Press / December 2, 2012)
A songbird called the streaked horned lark has a curious propensity for risky neighborhoods such as airports, Army training fields, and dredge spoil dumping sites. The bird is being considered for listing as an endangered species. | credit: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service |
A UW chemist wanted to do air-quality monitoring on the health effects of coal trains, but couldn
Climate change news
Climate warming greenhouse gas reaches 400 parts per million for the first time in human historyThe steep ramp on the graph is not good.
Safety issues make plans to clean up a mess left over from the construction of the U.S. nuclear arsenal uncertain
Which fish will get to recolonize the Elwha River in the biggest U.S. dam removal projects? The complex debate over wild and hatchery fish.